Loading

Best of City Island · Top 10 NYC

Skip to content

Lists Boroughs Buzzing Happening About Saved

of City Island · verified Jul 21, 2026 · By Piyush Puri, MD

Best of City Island

The 10 best places to eat and drink on City Island, from Belden Point fried-shrimp trays to a 1929 dockside dining room, all verified open in 2026.

1
Johnny's Reef Restaurant
City Island · 2 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464
Official site ↗·Map ↗verified 0d ago
Cafeteria-style fried seafood hall at Belden Point, the very tip of City Island, with picnic tables on an open deck over Long Island Sound. Cash-only trays of fried shrimp, whiting, scallops, clams and lobster since the 1950s.
Because the cafeteria line has been sliding trays of fried shrimp and whiting onto the same open deck at Belden Point since the 1950s, and the picnic tables still sit directly over Long Island Sound.
Order Fried shrimp platter
Bring cash, claim a deck table before you order, and keep a hand on your tray; the gulls patrol the railings like they own the place.

The map

Loading the map

More Bronx lists

Best Indian in the Bronx6 spots →
Best Dominican in the Bronx10 spots →
Best Tacos in the Bronx10 spots →
Best Italian on Arthur Avenue10 spots →

2

Sammy's Fish Box

City Island · 41 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464

Official site ↗·Map ↗verified 0d ago

Sprawling 500-seat seafood palace near the City Island bridge, known for gigantic lobster and shrimp platters and for staying open until 1 a.m. year-round.

Because it grew from a 26-seat snack bar in 1966 into a 500-seat house serving upwards of a million meals a year, and it stays open until 1 a.m. year-round when the rest of the strip has gone dark.

Order Lobster and shrimp platter

Go after 10 p.m. when everything else on the avenue is closing; this is the island's one dependable late-night lobster.

3

The Original Crab Shanty

City Island · 361 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464

Official site ↗·Map ↗verified 0d ago

Bib-wearing garlic crab feast house in a converted early-1900s silent movie theater, known for enormous family-style shore dinners like the lobster, shrimp and ribs feast.

Because the dining room is a converted early-1900s silent movie theater, and the family that took it over in 1977 still serves the garlic crab feasts that require a bib.

Order Family-style lobster, shrimp and ribs feast

Order a family-style shore dinner for the table and accept the bib without argument; the garlic sauce goes everywhere by design.

4

Sea Shore Restaurant & Marina

City Island · 591 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464

Official site ↗·Map ↗verified 0d ago

White-tablecloth-meets-marina seafood and steak house dating to 1929, with dockside dining over Pelham Bay and boat slips for customers who arrive by water.

Because it has served seafood on this dock since 1929 and still keeps boat slips so customers can tie up and walk straight to a table.

Order Dockside whole lobster dinner

Ask for a dockside table over Pelham Bay near sunset; if you have a boat, arriving by water is not a gimmick here, the slips are for diners.

5

Tony's Pier Restaurant

City Island · 1 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464

Official site ↗·Map ↗verified 0d ago

Johnny's Reef's across-the-street rival at Belden Point, a 276-seat cash-only fried seafood joint with a big pier over Long Island Sound and a live-lobster claw machine.

Because it burned down during Hurricane Sandy in October 2012 and reopened exactly one year later, and the rebuilt 276-seat pier still runs cash-only with a live-lobster claw machine by the door.

Order Fried whiting platter

Hit an ATM before you cross the bridge, then settle the eternal Johnny's-versus-Tony's argument yourself with a tray on the pier.

6

City Island Lobster House

City Island · 691 Bridge St, Bronx, NY 10464

Official site ↗·Map ↗verified 0d ago

Waterfront lobster specialist just off the bridge at the entrance to the island, with a deck on Eastchester Bay and a two-person ultimate lobster feast on the menu.

Because the two-person ultimate lobster feast served on a deck over Eastchester Bay has made it the island's namesake lobster destination for decades, and it stays open all year.

Order Ultimate lobster feast for two

It sits on Bridge Street just past the bridge, so make it your first stop before the avenue traffic backs up on summer weekends.

7

The Black Whale

City Island · 279 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464

Official site ↗·Map ↗verified 0d ago

Bistro-style New American restaurant with a garden patio, known for over-the-top desserts; it began in 1961 as an ice cream parlor and antique shop and still serves its 1960s dessert classics.

Because it opened in 1961 as an ice cream parlor, its windows were salvaged from the Freedomland theme park, and the original 1960s dessert classics are still on the menu.

Order One of the original 1960s dessert classics

Dinner starts at 4 p.m. Wednesday through Sunday, so aim for Sunday brunch in the garden between 10 and 2, and save room for dessert either way.

8

City Island Diner

City Island · 304 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464

Map ↗verified 0d ago

Tiny corner diner at City Island Avenue and Fordham Street, a classic small-town breakfast and lunch counter run by the same family for nearly three decades.

Because this corner counter at Fordham Street has been run by the same family for nearly three decades and is beloved enough that J.Crew put it on a vintage t-shirt.

Order The classic diner breakfast

It is a small breakfast-and-lunch operation, so come on the early side of a weekend morning before the counter fills with regulars.

9

The Snug

City Island · 302 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464

Map ↗verified 0d ago

Homey Irish pub attached to the City Island Diner, pouring pints alongside fish and chips and shepherd's pie since 2004; the island's neighborhood bar.

Because it has been pouring pints next door to the City Island Diner since 2004, and it is where islanders actually drink once the day-trippers head back over the bridge.

Order Fish and chips with a pint

It shares a wall with the diner, so treat the pair as a two-door crawl, and check the daily specials board the pub added in 2026.

10

The Artist (Starving Artist Café & Gallery)

City Island · 249 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464

Official site ↗·Map ↗verified 0d ago

BYOB cafe, gallery and music room serving coffee, light fare and desserts; City Island's bohemian living room, hosting open mics and shows for almost three decades.

Because it has anchored the island's arts scene for almost three decades, and the Chamber's 2026 calendar still lists its open mics, jazz workshops and comedy nights month after month.

Order Coffee and dessert during a live set

It is BYOB, so bring your own bottle and check the Chamber events calendar for open mic and Sunday jazz nights before you make the trip.

Editorial guides to New York. Ten picks per list, every borough.

of Chinatown

of Bay Ridge

of Astoria

of City Island

Indian

About

Who we are
How we rank
Editorial standards
Editors
Archive
Happening
Crown Jewels

3D model credits

Empire State Building by NanoRay, Brooklyn Bridge At Night by Asadawut Kaewma, and Old Ferris Wheel by Yevheniia Lenda, each licensed CC BY 4.0 via Sketchfab. Statue of Liberty model from Free3D.

City backdrop by Elias Vidal on Unsplash.

© 2026 Top 10 NYC. All rights reserved.Made in New York.

Reach us

hello@top10nyc.org