TOP10NYC
Pizza · May 14, 2026

The Ten Best Slices in New York

We ate three slices a day for six weeks. These are the ones that stayed with us.

  1. 01

    L'industrie Pizzeria

    Williamsburg, Brooklyn

    The burrata square is still the platonic ideal. Crust dignity intact at 8pm on a Saturday.

  2. 02

    Joe's Pizza

    Greenwich Village

    The plain slice that other plain slices aspire to be. Don't get the pepperoni.

  3. 03

    Scarr's Pizza

    Lower East Side

    The grain matters; the cheese matters more. Tomato sauce sings.

  4. 04

    Mama's Too

    Upper West Side

    Square heritage; corner-piece evangelism warranted.

  5. 05

    F&F Pizzeria

    Carroll Gardens

    Round, restrained, perfect under a single light bulb.

  6. 06

    Una Pizza Napoletana

    Lower East Side

    Cesarò margherita. $30. Worth it once a year, minimum.

  7. 07

    Lucali

    Carroll Gardens

    The reservation; the candlelight; the actual pizza. All true.

  8. 08

    Lions & Tigers & Squares

    Greenwich Village

    Detroit-style done right, with a crust that earns its caramelization.

  9. 09

    Roberta's

    Bushwick

    Bee Sting still earns the bee. Get one with the regular pepperoni for contrast.

  10. 10

    Patsy's

    East Harlem

    Coal oven. 1933. Order the half-pie cold from the fridge for breakfast tomorrow.